Should a would-be author concern themselves with Political Correctness?

by Adrian Sroka
26th February 2017

Why should a would-be author even bother to concern themselves with Political Correctness?

Let’s use ivory as an example. Would it be okay for an author to write about the brutal killing of Elephants and the Black Market in ivory? Would there even be an audience for such a book?

Similarly, would it be politically incorrect for an author to create a magical object partly made of ivory in a fantasy or magic-realism novel.

Authors have the same problems if they choose to write about race, ethnicity, class, religion, or crimes committed by a particular group - and of course politics.

What should a book contain to be Politically Correct?

Must it have Black, White and Asian characters? Must they all have to be from the same social class and background? Must it have left-wing and right-wing characters? Should there be an equal mix of Heterosexual, Lesbian and Gay characters?

Of course not, that would be incongruous.

A writer should write what he or she knows about and stick two fingers up to those who object. Why some of you may ask? It’s because we live in a democracy in which freedom of speech plays an active part in our daily lives – and long may it do so.

Under good old Joe Stalin, it was the death knell for creative artistic expression. Artists, Writers and Classical composers, were killed for not toeing the communist line. Russian art suffered severely as a consequence.

How dumbed-down and dull books would be if authors concerned themselves with every aspect of Political Correctness.

As much as aspects of Political Correctness have helped to civilise society, it is darkly oppressive at its core. At its worst, Political Correctness represents a virtual gagging filter placed between the thoughts of an individual and the vocal expression of them.

It is a social conditioning designed to seriously limit free expression and exchange of ideas.

Replies

'Political correctness' is about being a decent human being. End of.

Profile picture for user pennygad_46489
Penny
Gadd
270 points
Ready to publish
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Comic
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Historical
Philosophy and Religion
Penny Gadd
01/03/2017

Dear all but in response to the frogs -Emilie - big G prefers the canvas of her own hair these days and her medium is jam.

Jimmy- I loved what you wrote about why you write. I remember vividly the books that changes my life throughout my life. What links them is that they were all challenging. PC doesn't mean bland and difficult or controversial doesn't mean offensive. Indeed, offensive is often shallow and dull. The books that mean the most to me now are the ones I read with big G, the ones that make her ask questions. PC and challenging and exciting and funny and even, Adrian, books discussing the ivory trade, etc. Possible in even kids picture books!

Profile picture for user vickyjay_43963
Victoria
Fielding
270 points
Developing your craft
Fiction
Victoria Fielding
28/02/2017

Although - as far as I know - she has never been a refugee herself, 5yo G has used her IMAGINATION to put herself in 'another's shoes'.

Which, Mr. Sroka, is what Walk Two Moons by your beloved Sharon Creech is all about.

Isn't it?

Profile picture for user emilie@l_41018
Emilie
van Damm
330 points
Developing your craft
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Business, Management and Education
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Romance
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Emilie van Damm
28/02/2017