What books would you destroy to avoid them falling into other hands?

by Wilhelmina Lyre
3rd September 2015

We all know the evils of censorship: not ALLOWING people to read the books of their own choice.

But have you ever owned a book that was so BAD that YOU didn't want to be responsible - in the slightest way - for it to fall into other hands? A book that you'd rather burn or rip to shreds than donate to a charity shop... or even risk somebody else' pulling it out of your rubbish bin?

"If people WANT to buy it, I'm certainly not going to stop them. But I'm not going to FACILITATE their reading such a load of:

crappy plot;

evil values;

godawful writing style;

(other)."

Please give examples and reasons. Be as nasty as you wish.

I'll start off with a non-fiction book: "Duérmete, Niño" ["Go To Sleep Child"] by Eduard Estivill and Sylvia de Bejarby.

This is a cruel piece of shit that assures new parents that the best for their child is to cry themselves to sleep until they get used to the idea that nobody's going to come comfort them. ("You've got to keep firm. If you give in once and pick up your crying child, you set the whole learning process back by weeks.") They reassure parents that it's healthier for children to rock themselves back and forth rhythmically, banging their heads against the wall or the bars of the crib, than to be "spoiled" by being cuddled past their official bedtime. They KNOW that they couldn't convince parents to try this method for their own convenience, so they tell them that it's better FOR THE CHILD!

I first read about this book in Carlos González' EXCELLENT "Bésame Mucho: Cómo Criar Tus Hijos Con Amor" ["Kiss Me!: How to Raise Your Children with Love"], the BEST book on child-rearing that I've ever read. I later found the Estivill/de Bejarby book in a 2nd-hand shop. It was quite cheap, so I bought it... in order to burn it.

Reason for burning: a book of pure EVIL!

Replies

@ Wendy Taylor-Loftus ("The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne.

"We studied this for A Level English and had to compare it with The Colour Purple: The difference between the lives of women 100 years apart. I am still traumatized some years later. It is the only book I would like to burn.")

The whole POINT of The Scarlet Letter was to highlight the hypocrisy of some and the cruelty of others, the persecution of women, the INJUSTICES of life.

If you're going to burn every book that presents an unpleasant reality, I'd advise to stay clear of some of the best books ever written.

(Not that I'm saying that The Scarlet Letter is one of the best books ever written, but it WAS written to expose injustice and hypocrisy... and it succeeded.)

Profile picture for user emilie@l_41018
Emilie
van Damm
330 points
Developing your craft
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Business, Management and Education
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Romance
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Emilie van Damm
09/09/2015

The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne.

We studied this for A Level English and had to compare it with The Colour Purple: The difference between the lives of women 100 years apart. I am still traumatized some years later. It is the only book I would like to burn.

I Am Legend by Richard Matheson on the other hand... Fantastic!

Profile picture for user writer@p_41111
Wendy
Taylor-Loftus
270 points
Developing your craft
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Business, Management and Education
Food, Drink and Cookery
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Speculative Fiction
Wendy Taylor-Loftus
09/09/2015

Jimmy: Of course 'them' were the books!

(Terrible sentence that, but anything gets published in this little box.)

The Daisy Meadows army were free to leave and pursue other artistic endeavours (they probably insisted on a clause in their contracts that they wouldn't be 'outed' if they succeeded in selling under their own names) without a hair so much as straightened, let alone singed.

The books, too, I will graciously allow to exist unharmed (just not on my shelves).

Profile picture for user KatyW_
Katy
W
270 points
Ready to publish
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Historical
Speculative Fiction
Katy W
08/09/2015