Checks and Balances, Chapter One - Comments Appreciated

by Georgiana Derwent
10th June 2015

This is the first chapter of the novel I'm working on, Checks and Balances. It's a British thriller with dystopian elements, though perhaps its most interesting attribute is its "anti-heroine." I'd love to hear what people think. Thanks, G

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Peak District, Year Eight of the First Lord and Eternal Blessed First Lady’s Glorious Regime, June.

“We’re going to send Michaela to Somerset House and have her seduce and kill the First Lord.”

I glanced at Michaela, as she leaned against the reinforced metallic wall of our commandeered mine shaft’s control room. Her wavy, obsidian-black hair had grown out of the practical cropped style, we all sported, and into an elegant bob. She’d swapped her usual guerrilla outfit for a vintage silk gown that someone had decided would pass muster in London. The emerald dress showed off her curves and emphasised the beauty that shone through even in army fatigues, but that didn’t stop it being five years out of date.

“Derby and Hull have both been bombed this month for their sympathy to our cause. The army wiped out an entire platoon last week. There have been too many deaths, too many prisoners. We’re losing. We need to find out where the Regime is going to strike next, and we need to stop the First Lord once and for all.”

David stood under the screen that showed our hacked CCTV camera feeds. He crossed his arms. Years of outdoor living and physical labour had given them the muscular tone and hearty glow he could only have dreamt of in old life as an academic. His unblinking eyes and fixed mouth seemed to challenge me to defy him in front of all the local officers of the Treaty, whom he’d summoned to this underground meeting. He should have known; I could never resist a challenge.

“That’s insane. The First Lord has his pick off all the girls in the capital. Even if he did choose Michaela, she’d be a moment’s entertainment to him, not a military confidant, and she wouldn’t get within a mile of him with a weapon. Worse, there’s a chance that far from seducing him, she’ll be seduced and used against us. Julien can be very charming, very persuasive.”

“I am a loyal servant of the Treaty,” Michaela snapped. “I’ve been a member of the Treaty since it was founded, since I was a young girl. My father gave his life to kill the First Lord’s wife. The Treaty brought me up. I didn’t just walk in off the street with no history like you.”

I thought of the tiny, shy twelve-year-old I’d met when I’d first thrown myself on the Treaty’s mercy, five long years ago. I struggled to reconcile her with the beautifully arrogant seventeen-year-old ingénue in front of me.

I grabbed Michaela by her billowing, ribboned sleeves. “I didn’t walk in off the street, Michaela. I left behind my life as the wife of an officer of the First Lord’s army, because I believed in the cause. It’s easy to be loyal when you’ve known nothing else, when you owe the Treaty everything. I made sacrifices to serve.”

I’d told the lie so often. My mind conjured up a clear image of Oliver Bonham, the senior army officer who’d never existed. It amazed me that all of them, even David, had bought my story when I’d turned up at their camp and continued to believe it.

David grabbed hold of me from behind and broke my grip on Michaela’s arms. I trained every day, but my strength was still no match for his. “Desperate times call for desperate measures, Melanie. Everything you say may be true, but we need to try. We need to use every weapon at our disposal.”

“You’d know, I suppose. You and your PHD in politics.”

David claimed to be a working class hero, but he’d spent longer at Oxford than I had, and came from a much wealthier background. Token student protests about global warming and globalisation had mutated into something more extreme once the First Lord and Lady came to power. In a different world, he’d have become a professor and written the occasional scathing article for the New Statesman. Instead, he shot down helicopters and interrogated captured soldiers. As did I.

He released me, without rising to the bait, and turned to the computer’s controls. The Regime strictly controlled internet access, but the Treaty attracted plenty of support from the technological fringes of society. They’d managed to set up a functioning computer network underground, and made it possible not only for us to use the internet freely, but to view most security cameras at will.

David set the feed to show Somerset House from the Strand. Its elegant arches and columns formed a stark contrast to the grey, utilitarian network of abandoned mines and tunnelled caves. They weren’t home exactly, but were certainly the place where I spent my nights after long days of raids on nearby towns, manning anti-aircraft posts and watching out for Regime troops.

I tried not to torture myself with sights from my old life, but Somerset House’s beauty wasn’t what David wanted us all to reflect on. He wanted us to see the heavily armed soldiers guarding the gate and pacing the street. The helicopters hovering above. The giant banner with the First Lord’s winged unicorn insignia hanging above the archway, and the two even huger portraits that fanned down either side of it. Honour the First Lord demanded the one on the left, above an image of a striking man in fake nineteenth century military uniform. Remember the Eternal Blessed First Lady mourned its companion on the right-hand side. The woman in that painting looked as studiedly fragile and innocent as Marie-Antoinette’s idea of a shepherdess, despite the Treaty’s tendency to regard her as having been a psychotic she-devil.

They were all symbols of the Regime’s power and illustrations of why we fought. And in the case of the painfully rococo portrait of the Treaty’s most high-profile victim, a reminder of what the organisation could supposedly accomplish when it put its mind to it. All designed to make me agree that Michaela should take her chances.

“Let me go instead.” The words were out of my mouth before I could think through the implications of what I was saying, before I could consider the madness of it.

Everyone stared at me, trying to find the nicest way to raise the obvious objection.

“Look at yourself,” Michaela spat, after the silence had gone on too long. “Don’t you realise that you’re old? They say you were beautiful once, but you couldn’t seduce secrets out of a minor official anymore, never mind the First Lord.”

Her words stung, but I fought hard to keep any signs of hurt off my face. In my old, privileged life, I’d had every hope and expectation of still looking young and beautiful at thirty-five. Few things hold back the clock like wealth and power. The Treaty camp didn’t possess a mirror, but I could well imagine the changes wrought by five years of camping in the peaks and hiding out in abandoned mines, wracked by cold, hunger, and the constant fear of discovery.

David gave Michaela one of his patented “gentle looks.” An innocuous sideways glance, a half-smile. From anyone else, it would have been utterly unremarkable, but it shocked her into a guilty silence more effectively than a lesser man’s glare, or shouted reprimand, ever could have. The leader of the resistance could communicate a hell of a lot with just his eyes. He shared the trait with his greatest enemy.

David put a muscular arm round my waist, and I managed not to flinch. I’d almost grown used to his touch over the years. He’d never dream of forcing himself on a woman, and as far as he was concerned, I enjoyed our embraces every bit as much as he did. In reality, I slept with him because I needed security, I needed status, and I needed secrets. Plenty of women—those who fought for the Treaty and those loyal to the regime with overactive imaginations—found his cropped dark hair, bright eyes, and sculpted figure to be attractive, but I kept my heart safely out of proceedings. There was only one man I’d ever loved. Only one man I ever would love.

“Melanie, you’re still beautiful. Michaela was intolerably rude, but the central point is true. All the evidence shows that, like all powerful men throughout history, Julien takes mistresses in their late teens and early twenties.”

I put my hands to my head and tried to push away the awful mental images his words conjured up. How many mistresses had there been? How young and how beautiful?

“Precisely. He’s been there, done that. Michaela would be one in a long line. I could offer something different. We’re the same age, I believe, the First Lord and I. I can offer shared memories and experiences. I can wave my ex-husband’s name around and claim the Treaty have held me prisoner for all this time. If I pretend to provide him with information, perhaps I can get some in return. I believe Michaela when she says she’s committed, but you must have heard the stories. No seventeen year old can be relied upon to stand against his charm, his beauty, the glow in his eyes, the way he looks at people like he can see into their soul and makes them feel like they’re the only person in the room.”

No seventeen year old could resist the insistent touch of his hands. The arms that could make you feel protected against anything. The kisses that could make you lose all control.

“And you think you’re immune, do you? Far beyond that sort of childish infatuation at the grand old age of thirty-five?”

Now it was my turn to get “the look,” but I’d developed some immunity to that, too. I made determined eye contact, his blue eyes burning into mine. “I think I’ve had chance to develop a little cynicism. I think I’ve come to understand the games that people play at court. I think I’ve stopped believing in love. I’m quite confident that I can stand before Julien St John Helmsley without falling to my knees in paroxysms of lust and adoration.”

I’d never been less confident of anything in my life.

“Perhaps you’re scared.” The others had wisely stayed out of it so far, but now Christopher, David’s de facto second-in-command in spite of his youth, stepped into the fray. He looked like a taller and more muscular version of Michaela, with his cropped black hair and the huge, dark eyes that made him appear disconcertingly sweet. “You’ll send my sister because the end justifies the means, but you can’t bear the thought of your woman in the First Lord’s bed.”

Christopher perfectly calibrated his words, either an insult or a spur to action. David would never willingly admit to anything as traditional as jealousy or having a woman who was “his.” Furthermore, he prided himself on always putting the Treaty and the ultimate goal of overthrowing the First Lord and freeing the country over every consideration. He’d said a million times that he would give his life. The least he could do was give my virtue.

David punched the rickety lift doors. “Of course I can’t bear the thought of her in that bastard’s bed. I can’t bear the thought of any woman suffering that fate. I can’t bear the thought of the man who destroyed Nottingham, blockaded the north and took away the country’s most basic rights touching any woman or experiencing any earthly pleasure. I can’t bear the thought that he’s still alive, still ruling us all, after so many good men have died. I can’t bear the thought of him, full stop.”

David hated Julien. That was hardly unusual in our circles. People generally didn’t risk their life by joining the Treaty, unless they despised and disapproved of the First Lord and his Regime. But for most of my fellow rebels, Julien was an abstract symbol of everything that had gone wrong with the country. David hated him in an oddly personal way.

I touched David’s arm. He spun on me and raised his hand. For a second, my breath held and I braced myself, but he dropped his arm and regained composure. My breath released, and I was thankful not to face the same fate as the door. For all my grandstanding, I’d never been good with physical pain.

“We all feel that way,” I soothed. “And that’s why we have to do this, and we have to do it right. How exactly do you expect Michaela to get herself admitted into his presence? She could wander the capital for weeks and never find an opening. But as the returning wife of a war hero, I’m sure I could approach some colonel or other and beg an audience.”

David bowed his head. I had no wish to know what thoughts of old atrocities were running through his mind. The screams as Regime bombers turned Nottingham into a wasteland. Paul, the Treaty’s first martyr, tortured to death. Treaty Members and suspected Treaty affiliates rounded up and imprisoned or worse.

“You’ll both go,” he snapped. “Claim you’re distant cousins or something. Let the great ruler decide whether he prefers youth or experience. Just make him fall for one or both of you, make him talk, and then destroy him.”

Michaela and I nodded our heads in sync, all thoughts of our early argument put aside. David had spoken, and there was no point in arguing with him when he was in this mood.

“You’ll need to go to the infirmary and have them fit you with a hormonal implant,” I said to Michaela, gentler now. I touched the characteristic raised bump on my upper arm. “You’ll never pass as a loyal citizen without one, and we don’t want you to end up carrying the First Lord’s heir.”

Michaela shuddered—avoiding the implants was a key sign of resistance—but after a moment’s hesitation, she let herself into the lift—which was mercifully still functioning, despite David taking his temper out on it—presumably heading for the tunnel where we’d developed a makeshift health centre.

Why had I talked myself into this? An unknown, pretty commoner like Michaela could try her hand and would either strike it lucky or return home defeated. And if I were really the imprisoned wife of an army hero, I’d have a pleasant homecoming and perhaps some sharp questioning.

But I was neither of those things, and I’d face one of two fates. I’d be either shot on sight or welcomed back into the fold like the prodigal son.

I genuinely didn’t know what to expect. No one else would dare to make the decision, so my fate would be entirely in the hand of the First Lord. And while people called him many things, no one could ever accuse Julien St John Helmsley of being predictable.

Comments

Review of 2nd part:

A feisty heroine with a good head on her shoulders, capable of positive, decisive action when she finds herself in a sticky situation, and yet not immune to emotion. I like that.

However, I would suggest a few changes:

“Michaela carried the glamourous dress she’d modelled in her backpack”. This is clumsy. What was she thinking of, modelling a glamourous dress in her backpack? Why not “In her backpack [or even Hidden deep within her backpack], Michaela carried the glamourous dress she’d modelled for us at the meeting a few days earlier. Was it only a few days? After this time of sculking along like fearful animals, it seemed so far in the past. It was bizarre to imagine the unwashed, tired, scared creature beside me as that haughty beauty.”? Sorry, I got carried away...

“Thanks to the controls the Regime had put in place, we couldn’t take a train without showing ID or travel by road without passing several checkpoints. London was unreachable. Instead, we were heading on foot to York, where we’d throw ourselves on the mercy of the city garrison controlling the north. I’d introduce myself and seek safe passage to Somerset House and a re-introduction to court. I’d decide what to do with Michaela when we got there.” OK, so you've explained why Melanie is heading for York. But why does Michaela agree with this plan? Unless, of course, York is on the straight line / the “underground railroad” that connects the Treaty's GHQ and London. (In which case, how explain that Melanie surfaced by the Treaty so far off her original home base?) If Michaela isn't ever going to be able to take a train without special dispensation, what is she planning to do in York? Present herself at City Hall and order: “Take me to your leader. I'm sure that he'll want to fuck me.”?

And correct me if I'm wrong but shouldn't it be “the city garrison controlling the North”? Or even “the garrison controlling the North”?

“The soldiers’ long red coats wouldn’t have been out of place at Waterloo or Lexington, but they were Kevlar-lined and made to the latest technical standards.” Blaring contradiction. Such coats would have been VERY out of place at Waterloo or Lexington. They might have not LOOKED out of place at Waterloo or Lexington.

“I still struggled to regard them as a true threat.” Not wrong, but... how about “I still had to struggle [with myself (optional)] to regard them as a true threat.”

“The short soldier to my left hit Michaela in the stomach with the butt of his rifle and pushed her up against the tree as she screamed, and I snapped back to the reality of the situation.” Personally, I'd prefer “The short soldier to my left hit Michaela in the stomach with the butt of his rifle, and pushed her up against the tree as she screamed. And I snapped back to the reality of the situation.”

“the short man asked” No need to repeat. He's the last male mentioned. Hence: “he asked”

“You’re on a spy mission. The usual rules don’t apply.” Ludicrous that David hadn't given her strict instructions to waive her vow, nor rehearsals to “get it right: do it without sneering or flinching.” “Well, yeah, you can SLEEP with him. We NEED you to SLEEP with him. But if I find out that you've bowed to him – even if it IS expected of all loyal citizens – I'll have your guts for garters.”

“But the soldier who’d been holding me all along pulled me into a headlock. [...] my captor slammed his rifle into the back of my head. Sickening pain reverberated through me, before I slipped into darkness.”

a) Have you ever tried to slam a rifle into the back of the head of somebody that you're holding in a headlock? If not, then you shouldn't write about it.

b) If I were a soldier out on patrol, and I saw one suspect kill another, and then [the first suspect] announce that she's got special information for my commanding officer, I don't believe that I'd slam my rifle into her head. Slightly too much force (or a thinner-walled cranium on the part of the suspect) and she might not live to tell her special news to my commanding officer.

c) 3 soldiers are more than enough to strip-search a suspect, to ensure that she's not smuggling another weapon into the presence of the superior officer. But 3 soldiers would find it more difficult to carry an unconscious woman through uneven terrain... while keeping an eye open for ambushers.

Might I take this opportunity to say what a pleasure it is to review the work of somebody who understands the use of the hyphenated double-worded adjective? And whose grammar in general is excellent?

Looking forward to more...

Jimmy

Profile picture for user jimmy@ji_34235
Jimmy
Hollis i Dickson
1920 points
Ready to publish
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Media and Journalism
Business, Management and Education
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Jimmy Hollis i Dickson
19/06/2015

For anyone who's interested, here's the next part. Further comments are very welcome, but no one should feel obliged.

_____

God knows I felt no loyalty to the Treaty, but leaving them behind still disconcerted me. For years now, people had constantly surrounded me, and although I’d often had a sense of being trapped, companionship offered a degree of security. Now, even with Michaela at my side, I felt very exposed. Both Michaela and I knew how to fight and how to survive in the wild, but part of me still screamed that horrible fates awaited women who wandered alone in the wilderness.

Michaela carried the glamourous dress she’d modelled in her backpack, and I’d packed a similar relic of my old life. But for the rigours of the journey, we both wore our usual outfits of cargo pants and tank tops, with a padded jacket over the top. Thanks to the controls the Regime had put in place, we couldn’t take a train without showing ID or travel by road without passing several checkpoints. London was unreachable. Instead, we were heading on foot to York, where we’d throw ourselves on the mercy of the city garrison controlling the north. I’d introduce myself and seek safe passage to Somerset House and a re-introduction to court. I’d decide what to do with Michaela when we got there.

Freed from the need to impress the senior men of the Treaty, Michaela reverted to the sweet young girl I’d once known. Just like she had years ago, she besieged me with questions about the capital. About the court. About the ruthless men of the army and their glamourous wives. About Julien.

“Do you think he’ll take me as a mistress?” she asked one evening, as we walked through a rough path under low-hanging trees. The swagger in her voice when she’d talked about it in the camp had morphed into a kind of all-consuming fear.

I passed her the hip flask and she took a good swig of the moonshine within. It was a rough moonshine. I wished it was a single malt, but its fiery taste helped to keep away both the chill and the fear. “Honestly? I don’t know. I was only the wife of a mid-ranking officer, remember? I’m no expert on his whims.”

“They say he’s incapable of love. I hear what the refugees and defectors say. There are many mistresses, but there’s no emotion there. He sees the beautiful women as no different to the impregnable palace and the fine wines.”

I glanced at her. She looked as exhausted as I felt. We’d avoided all but the smallest villages, and these wild expanses sapped our energy. “The last thing you want is for him to love you. You can manipulate lust. Love can destroy everything in its path.”

She nodded. “It’s not true though, is it? The First Lord’s not genuinely incapable of love. The mistresses might be mere playthings, but I’ve seen the posters of his wife on foraging missions in the cities. The Eternal Blessed First Lady. The mistresses don’t get posters. Surely, they show he loved her, before my father killed her to break his spirit.”

I shrugged and resisted the temptation to point out that, far from breaking his spirit, losing his wife just seemed to have pushed Julien over the edge. I always wondered what had really happened to Christopher and Michaela’s father, Michael, who’d once been David’s second-in-command.

“Posters prove nothing. He just likes to remind people that the Treaty killed her. It helps to keep the populace’s mind turned against us.” David would have been proud of my rhetoric.

“Did you know her?”

It was useless. Two days walk from the Treaty encampment and Michaela’s had already filled her mind with romantic fantasies. If she came before Julien, he wouldn’t even have to turn on the charm. She was already in love with the idea of courtly love and tragic romance.

“The woman on the posters? Waist-length spirals of golden hair and tremulous blue eyes and a pious, innocent gaze? No, I never knew the Eternal Blessed First Lady.”

“But you knew the person behind the pictures?”

Perhaps sweet Michaela wasn’t as stupid as she looked.

“I met her once or twice, from a distance, at military events. I keep telling you, I was just the wife of a mid-ranking officer.”

“Halt! Who goes there?”

I cursed as the army patrol stepped out of the trees and onto the path, hemming us in. Normally, I walked with my senses finely attuned to any hint of danger, but I’d allowed myself to become far too absorbed in Michaela’s questions. She’d stirred up old memories until I’d lost all sense of my surroundings. Might they buy the line that I was the wife of a mid-ranking army officer?

The soldiers’ long red coats wouldn’t have been out of place at Waterloo or Lexington, but they were Kevlar-lined and made to the latest technical standards. The bright colours and elegantly lethal tailoring brought back memories of another time. Once, the sight of the First Lord’s army had meant safety. Once, they’d bowed. Even through my mounting panic, I still struggled to regard them as a true threat.

The short soldier to my left hit Michaela in the stomach with the butt of his rifle and pushed her up against the tree as she screamed, and I snapped back to the reality of the situation.

“Who are you and where have you come from?” the short man asked as he fiddled with his belt.

A second solider took a firm grip of my arm, but I seemed to offer less sport than Michaela.

The third solider, this one taller and scrawnier, addressed Michaela. “Respectable women don’t walk on the moors alone. Are you whores of the Treaty?”

When she didn’t answer, he walked over and slapped her face. At least it distracted the first soldier from whatever degradations he’d been planning.

“Is that a no? If you’re not some Treaty slut then bow before our beloved Lord.”

I swivelled my head around in panic, but of course, Julien wasn’t there in person. The third solider reached into his bag and pulled out a framed photograph of the First Lord. Even in a miniature reproduction at a distance of ten metres, his green eyes seemed to bore into mine. Tremors ran through my body, and my captor tightened his hold.

“Bow before the First Lord,” the soldier repeated, slapping Michaela again while the first solider loosened his grip to allow her space to accede to their request.

Bow, I willed Michaela. Just bow, once, and we might actually make it out of here alive. According to the new constitution, everyone must bow before the First Lord and before images and statues of him, which were everywhere. But when anyone joined the Treaty, they made a solemn vow never to do so, no matter the provocation. It’s one of our organisation’s defining features, and the rebel leaders had drilled the rule into Michaela since childhood.

You’re on a spy mission. The usual rules don’t apply. You were planning to sleep with the First Lord. Of course you have David’s dispensation to bow to his image to protect our cover.

Michaela shook her head and then spat at the image. I flinched, both with the foresight of what this would mean for the two of us, and an old remembered sense of wrongness, an old memory of the first time I’d seen someone defile Julien’s image.

The first soldier punched her in the face, and she slumped forward. Before, they’d been showing off their power and toying with a beautiful woman for their own twisted sense of amusement. Now, though, she’d angered them. It seemed Julien still had some truly loyal minions.

I thought of the gun in my pocket. I wasn’t the world’s greatest shot, but I was competent. David—and before him, my husband—had long ago made sure of that. If I could distract the guard who had me in his grasp, I could reach it and get one shot off before they overpowered me. The first soldier had his trousers around his ankles. It would be satisfying to shoot him in the face, before he could have his sick way with Michaela, but then what? The second I fired, they’d turn their guns on me.

I could see it all. She was going to talk. She was going to damn us as Treaty spies. But before that, she was going to suffer.

“How about you?” the man gripping me asked. “Will you bow before your leader?”

He released his grip on me and reached for an identical photograph. Pale skin. Black hair. Pronounced cheekbones and sculpted lips. I tried to avert my eyes. Holding an image of Julien this close to me was like thrusting a crucifix in a vampire’s face.

The sensible approach would be to bow, but the first soldier had a screaming Michaela on the ground, and I suspected that the moment for compromise and collaboration had passed.

“Actually, I’m not required to bow,” I replied.

“Everyone must bow before the First Lord,” he snapped.

I reached for my gun while the soldier remained bamboozled by his indignation. He flinched back at the sight of it, but I had no interest in him. Before anyone could gather their wits and try to stop me, I aimed and fired a single bullet straight into Michaela’s skull.

The shot was better than I could have hoped. She didn’t even have time to scream before her suffering—and the risk of her saying anything she shouldn’t—ended. I thought of the little girl I’d first met and of the sparky young creature I’d come to know over the last few days, with all her hopes of romance. I didn’t regret my decision, but that didn’t mean it didn’t hurt. Story of my life.

There was a moment of stunned silence, and in the confusion, I thought I might be able to get another shot off after all. But the soldier who’d been holding me all along pulled me into a headlock. The others drew their guns and surrounded me.

“Drop your weapon,” the second soldier cried.

I considered blurting out my whole story, but what were the chances of them believing me?

“I’ll drop it,” I replied, fighting to keep the tremor out of my voice. “Just promise me you’ll take me to the nearest barracks. There’s something I need to tell your commanding officer.”

The second soldier nodded. I dropped the gun, and at a nod from the second soldier, my captor slammed his rifle into the back of my head. Sickening pain reverberated through me, before I slipped into darkness.

Profile picture for user georgian_40042
Georgiana
Derwent
270 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Historical
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Georgiana Derwent
17/06/2015

Hi, Georgiana!

I´m not a big fan of thrillers, and the length of this piece made me think that I wouldn´t finish it. (It's now 1:29 a.m., and I've had a long day.) But I couldn't stop reading. Not true, but I didn't WANT to stop. It's gripping!

It makes me wonder whether Melanie has been a mole for 5 years and is grabbing a chance to return to her side with accumulated information, without raising suspicions within the Treaty. Or has she been spurned by the First Lord, and wants to carry out jealousy-fed revenge? Could she even be the "Eternal Blessed First Lady", mistakenly accounted dead by both sides? Creating a devious, secretive narrator is a wonderful ploy. I hope that you're planning to keep her secret from the reader for most of the book.

I'm glad that Lorraine got to this first, as she's thorough, and I agree with her that most - or all - of the objections to this work are of a grammatical nature. Reading through it, it was the unnecessary comma that irked, not the subject nor the style. However, I do disagree with her on a detail or 3, and she might possibly have missed the odd mistake.

I have no objection to the month coming after the year in the first line. It might be the style of the regime. Or it might indicate a wish to lend more detail to a dating previously considered complete. If the latter, I rather like it.

I consider ‘Her wavy, obsidian-black hair' to be more correct than Lorraine's correction: ‘Her wavy obsidian-black hair'. It's NOT a list: it's 2 adjectives qualifying the same noun. As such, they should be separated with a comma. Surely Lorraine wouldn't object to "She was a kind, generous person"? Or - to make the point more obvious - "She was a pretty good cook" does not mean the same as "She was a pretty, good cook".

"Comma not needed after 'Treaty' ". No, not needed. But also not wrong. There is a subtle difference in flavour to the sentence, depending on whether you leave the comma or suppress it. And you must be the judge of which flavour you prefer.

“I am a loyal servant of the Treaty,” Michaela snapped. “I’ve been a member of the Treaty since it was founded, since I was a young girl. My father gave his life to kill the First Lord’s wife. The Treaty brought me up. I didn’t just walk in off the street with no history like you.” If this were description, I might agree with Lorraine's objection to 3 "Treaty"s. But it's quoted speech. Given that the Treaty is so important to Michaela - important enough for her to prostitute herself, to kill and be killed for it - why shouldn't she name it 3 times in one speech? Anyway, if I were to write: 'The boy scowled at me and muttered. "It weren't my blemmed fowlt iffen she were a'cryin', were it, Mass'r?" ', would you accuse me of having a terrible grasp of the English language, or attempt to correct me?

Let's just remove one of those "Treaty"s and hear how false the result sounds COMING FROM MICHAELA: “I am a loyal servant of the Treaty,” Michaela snapped. “I’ve been a member of it since it was founded, since I was a young girl. My father gave his life to kill the First Lord’s wife. The Treaty brought me up. I didn’t just walk in off the street with no history like you." Sorry, that doesn't do it for me. Why not insist on removing one of those "since"s? My advice is to leave it as you wrote it.

Much as Word® tells me that I shouldn't have "sentences" without verbs, they are sometimes just what is called for. Another example of flavour. I prefer your ‘David gave Michaela one of his patented “gentle looks.” An innocuous sideways glance, a half-smile.’ to Lorraine's ‘David gave Michaela one of his patented gentle looks; an innocuous sideways glance, a half-smile.’ The inverted commas are also either a matter of taste or a matter of your intent. 'his patented gentle looks' raises the ridiculous problem of deciding whether to put in a comma or not: 'his patented, gentle looks' implies that he's taken out a patent on them. 'his patented "gentle looks" ' implies that all the women in the Treaty are well-acquainted with those looks, and are slightly sarcastic/sardonic about them. Frankly, I prefer the latter.

‘I made determined eye contact, his blue eyes burning into mine.’ I really can't understand her objection to this. Would she object to ‘I made determined eye contact, his blue eyes burning into mine all the while.’? You could always change it to ‘I made determined eye contact, while his blue eyes burned into mine.’ But, again, I prefer your original.

Well, slightly more than a detail or 3 on which we disagree. The important thing is that we agree that it's

Good stuff.

Jimmy

p.s. It's now 2:58 a.m.

Profile picture for user jimmy@ji_34235
Jimmy
Hollis i Dickson
1920 points
Ready to publish
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Media and Journalism
Business, Management and Education
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Jimmy Hollis i Dickson
16/06/2015