Are you a pantser, or did you plan your novel?

by Adrian Sroka
1st March 2017

Are you a pantser, or did you plan your novel?

Did you outline your novel, or simply proceed with the ideas that inspired you to pick up your pen?

I planned my novel from the beginning to the end, then wrote the first draft. However, I was far from satisfied with the end product. I realised that the ending didn’t have conformity with the beginning. But changing the ending and the beginning, meant doing a complete thematic and structural edit of my first draft. But as I did this, I had ideas for further improvement. After much rewriting and many thorough edits, I am happy with my manuscript, but I still have work to do.

How are you getting on with your novel?

Replies

Complete pantser here! When I started writing I had no idea where it was going. When I got stuck I would survey family members and steal their ideas. As I got further through I began to have ideas for a few scenes I would like to include, but the characters made their own ways there. As a result my first draft was very thorough, because I would change and rewrite things as I went, and I didn't have to do a structural edit because I needed it in place as I was going.

Once I finished the book I went back and made an 'after the fact' plan to help me with writing a synopsis and it taught me so much about my characters...but I couldn't have done it the other way round.

Profile picture for user hannah71_48295
Hannah
Dunn
270 points
Developing your craft
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Gothic and Horror
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Hannah Dunn
02/03/2017

Plan plan plan! I do character and plot outlines. Write little back stories of their lives before the book. I'm also an illustrator so I'm constantly doing sketches of characters and scenery to really feel a place before and during writing.

Profile picture for user hrdozier2
Harry
Dozier
270 points
Practical publishing
Poetry
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Food, Drink and Cookery
Speculative Fiction
Harry Dozier
02/03/2017

The novel (or novels -it's a trilogy) I am currently working on started out as a two page word exercise to break a bout of writer's block caused by comments on a previous project which was described as "would make a good sitcom, but curiously plotless for a novel."

Not what you want to hear.

From an agent.

So then I started thinking about that and other issues and now I've got so involved in this project, I don't want to write anything else.

The plot - and this has definitely got one - has gone through many changes and adaptations (I have completed all three books) and is still being worked on.

A friend of mine wrote the synopsis for all seven books in a fantasy saga before starting work on the first one.

If we were all the same, we'd probably be more dangerous. But less interesting.

Profile picture for user miriammo_49266
Miriam
Morrison
330 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Miriam Morrison
02/03/2017