Grammar in Published books

by Ninette Hartley
22nd June 2013

I'm reading a very good book right now, I started it just the other day. I'm enjoying it immensely but the writer keeps using the this expression,

she's sat....we are sat....

I'm sure this is wrong and it should be she's sitting or we are sitting...but perhaps I'm wrong.

I haven't come across him writing, ...I was sat...

yet..

I'm not even sure what conjugation of the verb this is I just know when I hear it or read it then it grates inside my head. Why would an editor let this go?

Any suggestions out there? Am I being too finicky?

Replies

personally I believe that when I am reading a book with "lazy dialogue" its displayed in a way to portray the accent or speech format of the character, although it does drive me up the wall when you find un noticed edits or mistakes in a book

Profile picture for user orpeus@l_28078
Daniel
Orpeus
330 points
Developing your craft
Fiction
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Daniel Orpeus
22/06/2013

I've been pulled up on something similar. 'I was sat..' is lazy speech transferred to narrative. Of course, it should be 'sitting', but perhaps this writer's treating it as a colloquialism;

I suppose it rather depends on the type of book as to whether it's acceptable or not. Sometimes little eccentricities like this just grate on the nerves ;)

Profile picture for user oldchesn_4270
Jonathan
Hopkins
6735 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Historical
Adventure
The writing process
The publishing process
Self-Publishing
Jonathan Hopkins
22/06/2013