One Star Review

by Suzy Stewart Dubot
19th April 2013

Do you appreciate footnotes or do they annoy you?

I took them out of my Regency romance because half a dozen people complained in the UK while others in the US said that it was interesting to pick up historical facts on the way.

One of my footnotes explained the origin of the Burlington Arcade, for example.

Replies

Pratchett's footnotes are a part of the story, maintaining the illusion of the story. They are the exception, rather than the rule, for me. I can see how "real world" explanations might interrupt the flow of the narrative. I prefer those sort of "supporting information" notes to come at the end of the book - with clear indications of what they refer to, or course.

I have a beloved, if rather battered, copy of "Mansfield Park" which comes with an introduction and extensive end notes. I very much enjoyed reading them, but I'm not sure I would want them as footnotes on each page.

Profile picture for user Kwillsen
Kell
Willsen
270 points
Ready to publish
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Kell Willsen
19/04/2013

Writing Regency, I thought it might be of interest to know something along the way about William Wilberforce (Clapham Sect), why the Regent was ruling in place of his father, how the Burlington Arcade came into being, John of Gaunt's Mistress (my story is about a lord's mistress) etc.

It seems the general consensus is for the end of the novel, if people can be bothered to look...

I can but try.

Profile picture for user suzy.dub_24505
Suzy
Stewart Dubot
270 points
Practical publishing
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Comic
Speculative Fiction
Historical
Romance
Suzy Stewart Dubot
19/04/2013

I've never seen footnotes in a novel, though frankly I prefer them to chapter- or end-notes in NF simply because it's easier than flipping back and forth. But do most readers actually bother to read them?

In fiction I've seen notes both before and after the story, though the latter seems more common. Personally I put notes at the end of my HF, mostly to explain what's fictitious and what's 'real' history. And I try to encourage reading with a (very slightly) humorous title - because I write about cavalry it's 'Author's Tail'

Whether that works or not is another matter :?

Profile picture for user oldchesn_4270
Jonathan
Hopkins
6735 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Historical
Adventure
The writing process
The publishing process
Self-Publishing
Jonathan Hopkins
19/04/2013