Plotters, pantsers, editors and rough drafters.

by Deborah Finn
24th April 2013

If you are a pantser, are you able to write really rough first drafts and just get to the end of the story before you start revising and editing? Or is it possible to be a pantser whilst also being an edit-as-you-go writer? i would think that typically pantsers are rough drafters, and plotters are edit-as-you-go. But perhaps it's possible to have a hybrid? Let's have a little survey! What type are you? I think I am the slowest of all creatures - the plotter who is an edit-as-you-go writer.

Replies

I'm a combo really. Try not to limit myself by rigid labels.

Though....I am an obsessive planner. I'm working on an epic fantasy series. Something terrible would be birthed if I wasn't! But then, when I have a chapter outline with key events and what not, I ,er, 'pants' the actual content.

I was part of a writer's circle for about two years, so I edited as I posted. I would also usually start a writing session by spell checking the last piece of writing...a sort of warm up rather than in depth editing.

I'm very glad that I have such a flexible method, I believe that it improved my writing vastly to keep taking different approaches, feedback, revision ect. Also when it came to actually editing the book entire....*shudder* It's a bloody intensive task as it is, the thought of doing that without ever having done any editing? Gasp.

Profile picture for user ms_a_fox_27245
A
Fox
270 points
Ready to publish
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Business, Management and Education
Food, Drink and Cookery
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Gothic and Horror
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
A Fox
30/04/2013

I am a complete pantser. I know the type of story I want to write and its overarching theme, but I then have a tendency of writing without any idea of where I am heading or what will take place in the story at all.

My most recent novel-in-progress sprang from the long-held idea that I want to tinker with writing an Arthurian-themed contemporary fantasy story, updating the elements of the legend into the modern day. I used the characters and world from my first novel's modern magical world and tied them into the legend. So far it's proving interesting and enjoyable for me to write.

I tend to worry about corrections right at the end when I do the dreaded mass-edits, but will also read back and edit as I go. This is particularly true when it comes to retro-fitting facts to the story. (EG: In chapter 2, the Lady of the Lake works in a public swimming pool. By chapter 7, she is back in a more traditional role, living in a lake and carrying the affectionate name of "the blonde in the pond". That one resulted in chapter 2 being edited to reflect chapter 7, and the previous novel being updated to reflect this change too.)

Profile picture for user robswrit_24154
Robert
Gill
270 points
Developing your craft
Robert Gill
29/04/2013

I edit what I have written the previous day, before I start writing my next passage of text.

I cannot move forward if I have nagging doubts about the plot and storyline.

I edit clunky sentences, and correct grammar and punctuation the best I can. I tighten up dialogue and streams-of-thought.

I do that knowing that what I have edited may not survive the final cut.

I hope that editing-as-I-go will save me time when it comes to doing many thorough edits of my completed manuscript.

I am just dedicated (or obsessed) with getting it right.

Profile picture for user Adrian
Adrian
Sroka
19900 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Historical
Middle Grade (Children's)
Young Adult (YA)
Adventure
Adrian Sroka
25/04/2013