Stuck in.

by Heidi Roberts
25th September 2012

So I'm writing a book where my main character is clinically diagnosed as being catatonicly depressed. If I write it without therapy will I become depressed? I've heard that sometimes those kinds of things happen to authors and they get 'stuck in' their characters lives.

Replies

Perhaps the character's inner disposition, or psychological experiences need to have been experienced/endured/suffered by the writer themselves. Personally I think Dostoyevsky is the best example of that; The Double, Crime and Punishment etc.

Profile picture for user rcutjur@_21715
Ralph
Cutting
405 points
Practical publishing
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Historical
Adventure
Ralph Cutting
25/09/2012

No. Categorically. Heart on sleeve moment - I have been clinically depressed, I have had my name entered on emergency lists, etc etc. I'm not looking for sympathy (I managed to get through it without resorting to medication) but I can tell you that depression and emotions (sadness, joy, grief, peace etc.) are very different.

As Zohaib points out, you feel sad when you write a sad part. Of course you do, you've just killed a character you know and love (or some other circumstances). But that's an emotional response. I would suggest it is impossible for depression to manifest itself unless it is helped along by chemicals (take the tragedy of Heath Ledger's Joker as a case in point, or bipolar disorder, which is a physical chemical imbalance) or by some profound personal circumstances which occur while you're writing - in which case, shelve your project, and return to it when (not if) you get better.

Whoo, that was serious, wasn't it? It's an important point though, which needs to be addressed - after all, we are what we read.

Profile picture for user mark.rud_11053
Mark
Rudd
330 points
Ready to publish
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Philosophy and Religion
Mark Rudd
25/09/2012

it happens. i am writing a simple novel, but whenever a sad part comes i feel the vibes i do get sad, i dunno it will effect ur life or not just telling you that your character plays some role in your life

Profile picture for user Zohaib Ahmed
Zohaib
Ahmed
1280 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Gothic and Horror
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Romance
Adventure
Speculative Fiction
Self-Publishing
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Creative Writing and Publishing
Zohaib Ahmed
25/09/2012