Is your protagonist male or female?

by Adrian Sroka
22nd September 2013

Is your protagonist male or female?

I wonder if most of the main characters in novels are the same sex as the author.

There are examples of famous writers have failed when they have based their novel on the opposite sex.

There are also famous authors who have intelligently avoided the pitfall of writing about the opposite sex.

‘The Professor’ by Charlotte Bronte is based upon her experiences in Brussels, where she was a teacher in 1842. Much of the same subject matter of The Professor was reworked from the perspective of a female student into Brontë's later novel Villette, which attracted MUCH HIGHER critical acclaim.

Jane Austen wrote about men in situations she was most familiar with. In her personal encounters with men. In situations when both men and women were present. But she knew little of what men spoke about in the absence of women. Austen avoided pitfalls by writing about what she knew.

Replies

Sigh the OP and later comments make me a bit sad. Thanks Michael & Victoria for the reassurance. Youth and inexperience will make some allowances...

Bu,t Adrian, the way your post degenerated into some odd claim that Austen knew her place, that Bronte was less successful because she didn't is....misogynistic nonsense.

I hope other commenters keep that in mind when reading. Is writing another gender to you own experiences truly that limiting when I doubt very much that you have personally experienced the sort of plot events (murder, mayhem, fantasy creatures/settings, ect ect) that are no doubt riddling your writing? Are differing dangly bits that fearsome?

The context of setting is also key: You society does not have to be ours, or is that exploration another limitation that is too foreboding?

Explore, learn, write I say.

Profile picture for user ms_a_fox_27245
A
Fox
270 points
Ready to publish
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Business, Management and Education
Food, Drink and Cookery
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Historical
Gothic and Horror
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
A Fox
24/09/2013

I find it very difficult to write the scenes between my two male characters when they are alone, obviously because I have no first-hand experience, but that doesn't mean I don't love doing it! It's the most challenging form of writing and really stretches you. Embrace it, I say.

Profile picture for user dividedheart
Victoria
Whithear
5200 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Comic
Contemporary
Romance
Young Adult (YA)
Speculative Fiction
Short stories
Writing and Editing
Victoria Whithear
24/09/2013

My main character is a woman

I have based her loosely on someone I know, I find it easier to think about how the character talks and acts.

Profile picture for user michaela_26885
Michael
Anstead
1000 points
Developing your craft
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Michael Anstead
24/09/2013