Confuse

by Sophie Scholl
30th January 2014

Hi! I am frustrated about being rejected about my story. Can anyone be kind enough to read my story and tell me what's wrong? Not creative? Childish? Just please be true and honest.

The story is based on last year's Writers&Artists Short story competition theme(freedom).

Replies

I think there is a difference between a beautiful story and a marketable story and I'm not sure where your story would fall in terms of genre. I completely empathise because in order to write the tale I wanted to write I had to let it fall between genres and that is going to make it almost impossible to place.

Have you thought about self publishing? I think my 'baby' is going to end up on Kindle but that's no bad thing, plenty of popular books start out that way.

Profile picture for user underthe_10519
Katie
Gerrard
270 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Comic
Food, Drink and Cookery
Media and Journalism
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Historical
Gothic and Horror
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Philosophy and Religion
Katie Gerrard
31/01/2014

Hi Sophie

I haven't read your story but I have been rejected. Loads and loads of times. It's normal when you begin to write seriously, and unfortunately it hurts. A lot. Even when you tell yourself it doesn't really matter, the fact is it does.

There's only one way to get over it, I've found, and that's to write better. I did, and so can you. You just have to want to enough to work hard at it. Because that's what most writing is: hard work. I don't think many successful writers simply sit down and let words flow out because they don't. At least not for me, anyway.

I wrote two novels in my teens/early twenties and thought they were brilliant. They weren't of course, and I learned that the hard way. When I went back to writing around eight years ago I'd learned a lot, so my efforts were far better, but it was still hard work.

Stick with it. Learn what you can from rejection because it makes you both a better writer and stronger person. But don't give up - sheer bloody-mindedness is a big help.

Best of luck :)

Profile picture for user oldchesn_4270
Jonathan
Hopkins
6735 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Historical
Adventure
The writing process
The publishing process
Self-Publishing
Jonathan Hopkins
30/01/2014

Hi Sophie. I hope you won't mind a novice making a comment. I have just read the beginning of your work and it reminded me of my novel when I thought I had finished it... I hadn't, I had filled in all sorts of connections in my head as I wrote and not on paper.I think there maybe some of that in your work, but as I said I'm a novice. It was only when, like you have done I asked people to tell me what they made of it that I realised how much work there was to do. mine is now double the length and again (I think) the gaps are filled so the reader understands what is in my head, that remains to be seen! Don't throw your work into the recycle bin rework it instead. Regards Paul.

Profile picture for user paul_garside
Paul
Garside
330 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Comic
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Gothic and Horror
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Adventure
Speculative Fiction
Poetry
Short stories
Writing dialogue
Editing
Literary agents
Proof reading
Cover design
Publicity and Marketing
Preparing Your Portfolio
Identifying Your Audience
Literary
Synopsis
Voice
Paul Garside
30/01/2014