Professional Editing. Yay or Nay?

by Mykie Hall
23rd October 2013

Whilst attending an on-line forum and interesting questions was asked which produced an interesting answer.

"should you pay for a professional to edit your work before sending to an agent/publisher?"

One of the answers from an anonymous source was really interesting and got me thinking.

He or she said: "Having your work professionally edited can be frowned upon by a good publisher/agent and may throw your ability to write into question."

Not sure I agree but wanted some opinion on it.

Replies

Wish I could edit my question ;) Thanks guys. All very much what I though but for some reason it made me doubt myself. Love this site it has really helped. Thanks again.

Profile picture for user mykie@ho_27304
Mykie
Hall
270 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Media and Journalism
Speculative Fiction
Gothic and Horror
Sports
Mykie Hall
23/10/2013

If I was sending a ms to an agent or publisher I wouldn't mention whether or not I'd had any professional help, so how would they know? If you struggle with spelling/ grammar an editor can help you present your work in the best possible light, but I don't think many publishers expect to find a ms that they can't improve.

I would only pay for editing if I was self-publishing a book because I know (from experience) that no matter how carefully you think you've checked your own work mistakes do slip through!

Profile picture for user lindadau_1187
Linda
Daunter
230 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Short stories
Competitions, opportunities and groups
Self-Publishing
Arts, Crafts and Architecture
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Creative Writing and Publishing
Writing and Editing
Illustration
Publicity and Marketing
Linda Daunter
23/10/2013

There's no shame in using an editor, and I doubt agents or publishers would really care (it's not the kind of thing you need to mention in submissions). The only thing that makes me wary is that some editors can take a lot of money from less experienced writers. As long as the company / individual is legitimate and you know what you're getting, there's no harm. Personally, I've never used one, but that had more to do with my approach to writing than any universal publishing rule.

The comment about 'throwing into question' sounds more like snobbery than wisdom!

Profile picture for user simonphi_5040
Simon P.
Clark
270 points
Practical publishing
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Philosophy and Religion
Simon P. Clark
23/10/2013